Card & Comic Shops in Staten Island

5 shops · New York

Staten Island turns up 5 card and comic shops — 4 comic-forward, 1 cards & collectibles. The best-reviewed is The Dorf Knight Comics & Collectibles, 5.0★ across 11 Google ratings. Listings below are pulled from Google, deduped, and checked for closures — hours and ratings shown as Google reports them.

JHU Comic Books ★ 4.7 (270) Comic shop · 299 New Dorp Ln

Hypno-Tronic Comics ★ 4.8 (147) Comic shop · 156 Stuyvesant Pl

The Collector's Cave ★ 4.8 (140) Cards & collectibles · 4011 Hylan Blvd

Newbury Comics ★ 3.4 (91) Comic shop · Staten Island Mall, 2655 Richmond Ave

The Dorf Knight Comics & Collectibles ★ 5.0 (11) Comic shop · none

UPCOMING SHOWS IN NEW YORK

Sep 25–27, 2026White Plains Card Show White Plains, NY

Dec 11–13, 2026White Plains Card Show White Plains, NY

All New York shows →